I hate chores. They are the bane of my existence. Seriously.
Oh, not my own chores–my kids’ chores. I can do my own chores quick and easy, having had years of practice. I can have the house in semi-decent order within 30 minutes and not break a sweat. Mind you, we aren’t talking sparkling clean here, but pleasantly tidy.
And my kids, in those same 30 minutes, can merrily decimate the place without breaking a sweat.
How nice, no sweat.
Sadly, they can do this multiple times a day, so no matter how many times I clean up, the mess returns within an hour or two. It makes me want to rip my hair out. It makes me turn purple, jump up and down, scream, swear, and basically behave like an ill-mannered two year old. How very becoming of me, yes?
So my kids have chores. In short, they essentially must clean up their own messes. That includes wiping down counters, sweeping, vacuuming, making beds, etc. Mind you, I do all the same things when I am home and awake, but my general philosphy is that, if I am not even home or awake to make the mess (i.e., I’ve worked all night and been asleep), I refuse to be the one who clean up.
This works astonishingly poorly. I come home from work and the house is slightly messy. I get up after sleeping and the house is even more messy. After a few days of this, I go ballistic. The house gets clean, at the cost of my elevated blood pressure, stress-level, and the boys sense of self-esteem. Repeat ad nauseum.
It’s a constant struggle. I want the house to be somewhat tidy–particularly the kitchen and bathroom. I don’t like bugs in my house, I consider a dirty bathroom to be a health hazard, and I refuse to cook in a dirty kitchen. Seems reasonable to me, and, when explained to the boys, it seems completely reasonable to them. They also agree that, given I work very hard and I am not the one making the messes, they should pitch in and clean up after themselves.
It is all very reasonable. Sadly, children, in general, do not seem to follow general logic in their day-to-day lives. Baffling, but true.
For instance, most parents have likely noticed that children suffer from selective blindness. I would say it is a guy thing if it weren’t for the fact that I have come across many adult females with the same issue. Take a child, point to something that needs picking up or cleaning, and they will look anywhere but at what you are pointing at. They will walk right by it 50 times without seeing it. While you stand there in exasperation shouting, “It’s RIGHT THERE! For pity’s sake, look where I am pointing!” They will look all around in utter confusion, unable to locate the offending area/item. It is as if their ability to play “what here doesn’t belong” has failed utterly because, in fact, everything belongs. Mess and all.
So we make a list of daily chores, a la Flylady. A morning routing, and afternoon routine, and an evening routine. Simple, straightfoward routines, none of which should take more than 15 minutes to complete. A total of 45 minutes a day to complete all cleaning. How tidy.
Yeah, right. What should take 15 minutes, for some reason, takes about an hour. I have not figured out what time-warp is causing wiping down the counter to to take 20 minutes, but there it is. I wouldn’t mind if they were simply having a good time and being relaxed about it, but it is more along the lines of a major trauma. Why? No idea. And really, if is that much of a trauma, wouldn’t it make sense to do it as quickly and efficiently as possible, so one doesn’t drag out the pain of it?
There I go with that phenomenally useless logic again. When I mention the above idea to the boys, they nod their heads sagely and marvel at the wisdom the years have granted me. Then they take another 30 minutes to be traumatized by wiping down the counters. Oy.
When I attended the Unschooling conference this past September, it was put about that children should not have chores per se. Rather, one sets an example by joyfully and givingly cleaning up one’s house and doing for others. The Dalai Lama somewhat echoes this with his messages of compassiona and service. At first blush, it is a ridiculous notion to not hold children accountable for the messes they make. The Radical Unschoolers shift the ideology to state that it is actually the parent who wants the place cleaned up, not the kids, so it is the parent’s problem, not the kids. Setting a good example of service and caring will, it is assumed, eventually inspire the children to do the same and one will eventually find oneself being helped.
I raised the question of what to do when one gets overwhelmed by the sheer unendingness of a life that moves from work to sleep to cleaning in an ever-repeating cycle. How does one deal with matters when one’s children make a giant mess while one is sleeping, then again when one is at work. It is lovely that the kids can experiment by making volcanoes in my kitchen, but if I am spending all my time cleaning, working, and sleeping, I will soon end up in the funny farm. Additionally, if this method works so well, how is it that I have met so very many adults who constantly assume someone else should be cleaning up after them? Adults who think someone else will do their dishes, their laundry, their cooking?
In raising these questions at the homeschooling conference, I garnered many pitying looks, as though I just didn’t get it. It was suggested that perhaps I should consider hiring some help if I couldn’t handle the cleaning on my own. And these adults who didn’t do anything as menial as housework for themselves, well, that probably had nothing to do with the fact that their mothers did everything for them when they were growing up. It likely had more to do with the attitudes they were raised with. And, really, it was obviously something I needed to work on myself. In short, I got a lot of irritating non-answers. I don;’t like being irritated. It makes me think too much about whatever has irritated me. Mainly because I am usually certain I should not be irritated. Make sense?
And I’m left working on it myself. Clearly, having a major cow everytime something isn’t cleaned up is not working. Hasn’t worked in 12 years. Probably won’t work in the next 12. Nor can I simply decide to do all the housework–not only am I not convinced that will work, but I simply do not have that kind of time. By “not convinced that will work”, I mean in the long run, I don’t actually see that I am doing my children a service. Try as I might, I simply can’t see it. Perhaps that is where the pitying looks came from. Perhaps I am simply mentally deficient in this area. And the suggestion that I hire someone to do the cleaning I can’t do is financially out of the question.
So where does that leave one? Consider this–children, even a 12 year old–do not live in the same mind-frame as an adult. They live in a world of shifting importances and a need to keep their parents (and other authoritative adults) happy enough that they do not leave them. Harsh sounding, I know, but the fact is that a child’s biggest fear is that they will be left alone, to fend for themselves. Now, you and I logically know that most parents aren’t going to leave their kids on the nearest street corner, regardless of how pissed off they get but, as we have already pointed out, children’s logic does not seem to run in the same ways as adults.
So my kids try to please me and feel fear when they perceive they don’t, whether that perception is real or imagined. What a ridiculous thing in life when a dirty countertop causes fear in a child, however slight that fear might be. Some kids will feel it more or less than others, depending on their temperament. Yet the counter needs to be cleaned or it will, in fact, start growing unpleasant things, and if I do it all the time, I will eventually break down from being constantly overwhelmed. Seems like a no-win situation.
However, I think there is an answer. It is taking a lot of time and redirecting my thinking and, frankly, isn’t all that comfortable for me, but there is a middle ground. It seems to be taking months to get it even slightly balanced out, but it might work.
When I see the counter (that poor counter is taking a beating here) dirty, instead of pitching a fit because I didn’t make the damn mess and shouldn’t have to clean the damn mess up, ask a kid to clean it up. But don’t leave it there. Help them. Now there are two people cleaning up and the mess goes fast. When one kid is doing the dishes and looks like the world has just come to an end because they have to do this task, remind them to simply ask for a little help. The chores need to be done, but it seems to me there is nothing wrong with asking nicely for help. Half the problem here seems to be that everyone is very conscious of how much work the others are doing and constantly comparing it to make sure the others don’t have to do less. I start it with insisting I shouldn’t have to clean up other people’s messes, and the boys continue it by constantly pointing out to the others “I did the bathroom, so you should do the kitchen and living room!”
Take that comparing and complaining out of it. All jobs are everyone’s responsibilities. Every job in the house belongs to each person. Everyone in the house is welcome to ask for help. Everyone is the house is expected to give some level of help, as they are able. Everyone is expected to lighten the load of those around them. Including me.
Its a nice idea. It’s an idea that is hard to remember when in the midst of things or when one first wakes in the morning. And yet, it sucks to have chores be the bane of one’s existence and, as much as that is currently true for me, it is doubly true for the boys.
So we keep trying, and we can see that this idea can work. Things need to get done, for the peace and health of our hosuehold. The place doesn’t need to sparkle. In fact, I wouldn’t much like to live in a shiny perfect house. But there is a degree of cleanliness required for comfort and health (mental and physical). People can argue what that level is into the ground–it doesn’t make it any less true that the state will condemn your home when the rats and roaches invade.
So yes, the Radical Unschoolers are correct (to my thinking) on one level. You have to figure out what works for you and your family. Individual chores don’t work for us without a lot of pain on all sides. Taking the responsibility completely on myself doesn’t work either–it is simply too overwhelming on top of all the other responsibilities of being a single working parent of three very active jobs. Very pretty to think that one’s kids didn’t ask to be born and that one is, in fact responsible for everything in their young lives, but the reality is it is sometimes simply too much.
We will be not-quite-Radical Unschoolers for a little while longer, I think. We will see how this intercooperative little hive mentality works for us. And maybe my blood pressure will stay within acceptable ranges. I’m working on it.